Why Did My Car Insurance Increase? Your Guide to Auto-Insurance Premiums
If you’ve recently received your auto insurance renewal and noticed a substantial increase in your auto insurance premiums, you’re not alone. Many vehicle owners face a rate increase that can leave them asking: Why did my car insurance increase?
Understanding the factors behind rising auto insurance rates can help you make smarter decisions about your auto insurance policy and potentially lower your insurance premiums in the future. In this article, we explain the most common reasons for premium increases, what influences the average cost of auto insurance, and what you can do to manage your auto insurance costs effectively.
How Much Does Auto Insurance Usually Cost in Quebec?
In Quebec, the average cost of auto insurance typically ranges between $500 and $2000 per year, depending on various factors such as the driver's age, driving history, vehicle type, and coverage level.
Quebec has one of the lowest average car insurance premiums in Canada due to its unique public-private hybrid system: basic bodily injury coverage is provided by the government through the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec (SAAQ), while private insurers offer additional coverage such as property damage and third-party liability. As a result, car owners in Quebec often benefit from more affordable insurance rates.
Car insurance cost: How much you pay per month on average in Canada
9 Key Factors That Drive Increases in Auto Insurance Rates
Auto insurance rate increases are influenced by a range of personal and industry-wide factors. Understanding what drives these changes can help you make informed decisions about coverage options, insurers, and how to manage your auto insurance premiums effectively.
1. Driving Record and Fault Accidents
Your driving record is one of the most important factors influencing your car insurance premiums. Claims, whether at-fault or not, can significantly increase rates because they indicate a higher level of risk to insurers.
Similarly, even a single speeding ticket or traffic violation can result in a premium hike, since these infractions reflect risky driving behavior. To keep your insurance costs down, it's essential to maintain a clean driving record. Additionally, completing certified driver training courses can make you eligible for discounts and demonstrate to insurers that you are a lower-risk driver.
2. Cost of Repairs and Vehicle Repair Costs
The cost of repairs after an accident directly impacts your auto insurance premiums. Higher vehicle repair costs translate into more expensive insurance claims, pushing insurance companies to raise their rates.
For example, cars with expensive parts, complex engine types, or specialty vehicles like electric vehicles may cost more to repair. Claims involving these cars can lead to increased insurance premiums.
3. Increase in Insurance Claims and Catastrophic Claims
According to Transport Canada, there were 118,838 transport-related injuries in 2023. When there is a rise in the number or severity of insurance claims in your area, it drives up the cost of auto insurance. Catastrophic claims, such as those caused by extreme weather events (floods, hurricanes, hailstorms), are especially costly.
Private insurance companies must cover these high expenses, which leads to higher insurance rates for everyone. In regions with high accident rates, auto insurers adjust their premiums accordingly.
4. Changes in Coverage Options and Types of Coverage
Adjusting your coverage options or adding extra types of insurance can lead to higher premiums. For example, choosing comprehensive coverage offers broader protection—such as coverage for theft, vandalism, or weather damage—but also increases your overall insurance costs.
Your decision between mandatory basic coverage and optional add-ons, as well as the type of system your province uses—such as a no-fault, fault-based, or hybrid (partial no-fault) system—will also influence how much you pay in premiums upfront.
5. Type of Vehicle and Vehicle Rates
The type of vehicle you drive significantly influences your insurance rates. Passenger vehicles, SUVs, trucks, and specialty vehicles like classic cars or electric vehicles each have different risk profiles and repair costs.
Insurance companies assess factors such as vehicle type, engine type, risk of theft, and repair complexity. Vehicles with high theft rates or expensive parts often carry higher premiums. If you recently changed cars, this could explain a sudden substantial increase in your premiums.
6. Marital Status and Demographics
In Quebec, personal factors such as age, gender, and marital status can influence your private auto insurance premiums, which cover things like property damage and third-party liability.
Married drivers often receive lower premiums, as they are statistically associated with lower claim rates. Similarly, relocating to a different area—especially one with higher traffic density, accident rates, or vehicle theft—can lead to increased premiums due to regional risk adjustments.
7. Insurance Market Dynamics and Operating Expenses
Car insurance premiums are closely linked to market dynamics and insurers' operating costs. Factors such as labor shortages, rising vehicle repair costs, and increased claims processing expenses are all contributing to higher costs for insurance companies.
To remain profitable and meet return-on-equity expectations, private insurers may pass these increased expenses onto consumers through higher premiums, even in relatively stable regions like Quebec.
8. Changes in Legislation and Auto Insurance Reform
Regulatory changes and auto insurance reforms can directly impact premiums, especially when they affect claim costs or insurer obligations. For example, reforms that expand or reduce accident benefits, such as medical expense coverage, may shift the cost burden for insurers, potentially leading to premium increases.
While some provinces have introduced rate freezes or caps to protect consumers from rising premiums, these measures are usually temporary and may not prevent future increases once lifted. In Quebec, although the SAAQ handles basic bodily injury coverage, reforms to private insurance regulations—such as changes in how insurers assess risk or set rates—can still influence overall insurance costs.
9. Usage-Based Insurance and Driving Habits
Usage-Based Insurance (UBI) is increasingly available in Quebec and other provinces, allowing insurers to set premiums based on real-time driving behavior. Factors like mileage, speeding, hard braking, and phone use are tracked using telematics devices or mobile apps.
If a driver exhibits unsafe driving habits or significantly increases their mileage, premiums may rise. Conversely, drivers who demonstrate safe and consistent habits—such as avoiding harsh braking and driving less frequently—can benefit from discounted rates.
How to choose a car insurance broker in Quebec
Tips To Manage Your Auto Insurance Costs
Managing your auto insurance costs starts with understanding your policy, comparing rates, and adjusting coverage to suit your needs. These simple strategies and informed choices can help you reduce premiums while maintaining adequate protection for your vehicle and personal liability:
Shop Around and Compare Insurance Quotes: Because insurance premiums vary across insurance companies, obtaining multiple insurance quotes from various providers can help you find more affordable auto insurance. Working with an insurance broker or insurance agent, such as OVC Assurance, provides expert guidance on the best insurance policies and coverage options for your needs.
Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Be vigilant, avoid speeding and traffic violations. A clean driving record is rewarded with more favorable premiums from most insurers.
Consider Your Vehicle Choice Carefully: The type of vehicle you drive has a direct impact on your insurance premiums. Cars with lower repair costs, strong safety records, and reduced theft risk typically qualify for lower insurance rates. Insurers consider factors such as repair expenses, theft likelihood, and overall operating costs when calculating premiums.
Opt for Usage-Based Insurance: If offered by your current insurer, enrolling in a usage-based program may provide discounts if you demonstrate safe, low-mileage driving habits.
Review Your Coverage Types: Periodically reassess your auto insurance coverage to ensure it aligns with your current needs. You may be paying for coverage you no longer require—such as collision or comprehensive on an older vehicle—so adjusting or removing unnecessary coverage can help reduce costs without compromising essential protection.
Leverage Discounts and Payment Plans: Speak with your insurance broker about available discounts, such as those for completing driver education courses, bundling home and auto policies, or installing anti-theft devices. Additionally, choosing annual or semi-annual payment plans instead of monthly installments may qualify you for reduced service fees or premium discounts.
How to get car insurance: A simple guide to finding the right coverage
Secure a Great Price for Your Auto Insurance With OVC Assurance
OVC Assurance delivers a personalized and efficient insurance brokerage service, helping clients save both time and money. With access to over 20 insurers through a single point of contact, our experienced brokers handle the comparison process for you—ensuring you receive the best coverage tailored to your unique needs.
We provide comprehensive insurance solutions, including car, home, and recreational vehicle insurance, all under one roof. Clients benefit from direct, responsive communication by phone or email, along with support from our dedicated claims assistance team, making your insurance experience simple, seamless, and stress-free.